Why study a foreign
language?
By
Bernadette Morris
Foreign language study
enhances academic skills, raises
SAT scores, and prepares
students for careers.
Over the past two decades,
countries in the world have
become more and more
interdependent, and new
technologies have erased many
existing borders. As boundaries
between countries are dissolved,
foreign language instruction has
become more necessary than ever
for linking with the rest of the
world and for producing an
enlightened citizenship able to
function in today’s
ever-shrinking world.
The need for foreign language
study
Economic development
To be competitive on a global
scale, the business world of
tomorrow needs individuals who
can work in a culturally diverse
environment and who have strong
skills in a foreign language.
U.S. companies have committed
many faux pas when
attempting to market their
products abroad. One such
example involves a major
American airline company wanting
to advertise its new leather
first class seats in the Mexican
market. It translated its "Fly
in Leather" campaign literally
as "Vuela en cuero," which means
"Fly Naked" in Spanish. One can
only imagine the embarrassment
that must have ensued.
Additionally, many businesses
are looking for people who are
proficient in other languages.
Such skills are needed in
service industries (hotel,
tourism, food); publishers and
entertainment industries (films,
radio, and sound production);
corporate offices with overseas
accounts; and also in other
areas such as medicine, law,
business, journalism, and more
general government work. Knowing
another language provides a
competitive edge in career
choices in today’s and
tomorrow’s world.
National security
Once again, the connection
between languages and national
security has risen to the
forefront. In the past decades,
the US government has relied
heavily on technical means for
gathering intelligence; however,
the events of September 11 have
highlighted the shortage in the
manpower needed to translate the
messages gathered through
intelligence. In the wake of
September 11, there was a rash
of requests for speakers of
other languages. Lack of foreign
language expertise will continue
to undermine national security,
because the only way to get the
deep understanding of another
country that is needed for
intelligence operations is to
master the language spoken there
Cultural understanding
A less obvious but
nonetheless compelling reason to
study another language is the
power that languages have to
promote understanding between
people of different cultural
backgrounds. The study of
another language helps students
develop a sense of cultural
pluralism, an openness to and
appreciation of other cultures
(Carpenter and Torney; Hancock
and Lipton et al.; Lambert and
Tucker). Only through their
languages can we understand
other cultures.
Diversity
In the world of work,
managers who know how to deal
with a diverse workforce will
have an edge as minorities keep
moving to North Carolina. The
workplace of tomorrow will be a
world of many cultures and
languages. According to the
Kiplinger Washington Editors,
the Hispanic share of the
workforce will increase by 25
percent by 2010, and the Asian
share by around 50 percent.
North Carolina is already being
deeply affected by its growing
non-English-speaking population.
The last census reported a large
increase in the Hispanic
population of North Carolina. In
addition, 60,000 students who
speak over 170 different
languages are enrolled in our
public schools.
Benefits to students
Academic benefits
The study of another language
affects academic areas as well.
Research has shown that children
who have studied a foreign
language in elementary school
achieve higher scores on
standardized tests in reading,
language arts, and mathematics
than those who have not (Masciantonio,
Rafferty). The results of the
Louisiana Report on foreign
language and basic skills
(Rafferty) show that regardless
of their race, sex, or academic
level, students in foreign
language classes outperformed
those who were not taking
foreign languages. Foreign
language study has also been
shown to enhance listening
skills and memory, and the
development of second language
skills can contribute a
significant additional dimension
to the concept of communication.
Furthermore, students who have
studied a foreign language
develop greater cognitive skills
in such areas as mental
flexibility, creativity,
divergent thinking and higher
order thinking skills (Foster
and Reeves; Landry; Rafferty;
Ginsburg and McCoy).
Data from the Admissions
Testing Program of the College
Board show a positive
correlation between SAT scores
and the study of a foreign
language. Verbal scores of
students increased with each
additional year of language
study. Interestingly, the verbal
scores of students who had taken
four or five years of foreign
language were higher than the
verbal scores of students who
had taken four or five years of
any other subjects.
Enhanced career opportunities
As noted earlier, the
knowledge of other languages
will be a valuable asset in the
workplace of tomorrow. Workers
will be called upon to cooperate
with colleagues in other
countries, crossing time zones,
languages, and cultures.
Issues to consider
One must not assume that
language learning is quick and
painless. To truly learn a
language, one must have the
opportunity to learn early.
Neurobiologist Carla Shatz
believes that there are windows
of opportunity for learning that
open and close throughout a
person’s life. The implication
is that if you miss the window
of opportunity for learning a
particular skill or concept, you
are playing with a handicap.
Obviously, learning continues to
take place throughout a person’s
life, but the optimum time for
learning occurs until the age of
10 or 12, when the brain of
young children is believed to be
most receptive (Chugani). For
this reason, early language
learning is most effective when
it is started early on in a
child’s life. Researchers
believe that the window begins
to close around the age of 7 or
8. Another equally important
factor in language learning
involves the length of time
devoted to it. To become
proficient in another language,
learners must progress through
various overlapping stages
spanning several years, just as
they did when they acquired
their first language. They must
also consider the difficulty of
the selected language. Some
languages, such as Russian,
Arabic, Chinese, Korean, and
Japanese, take longer for native
English speakers to acquire than
others more closely related to
English.
Conclusion
If education is a means to
prepare students for the
complicated world they inhabit,
then the educational system
cannot deprive students of a
general education in the area of
foreign language. The value of
such an education not only lies
in job preparation but also in
developing an understanding of
other people and cultures.
References
Chugani, H. (1993).
"Reshaping Brain for Better
Future." As quoted in Chicago
Tribune, April 15. Cohen, P.
(1995). "Understanding the
Brain." Education Update.
ASCD. Cooper, T. (1987).
"Foreign Language Study and
SAT Verbal Scores." Modern
Language Journal 71, pp.
381-387.
Gingsburg, H. and McCoy, I.
(1981). "An Empirical Rationale
for Foreign Language in
Elementary Schools." Modern
Language Journal 65, pp.
36-42.
Hirsch, J. Quoted in Winslow,
R. (1997). "How Language Is
Stored in Brain Depends on Age."
Wall Street Journal, July
10.
Krashen S. and M. Long et al.
(1982). Child-Adult
Differences in Second Language
Acquisition. Rowley, Mass.:
Newbury House.
Olsen, S. A. and L.K. Brown
(1992). "The Relation Between
High School Study of Foreign
Languages and ACT English and
Mathematics Performance."
ADFL Bulletin 23, No. 3.
Rafferty, E. A. (1986).
Second Language Study and Basic
Skills in Louisiana. Baton
Rouge: Louisiana Department of
Education.
